15.7 C
Monday, November 23, 2020

A student loan bailout would do almost nothing for the economy

Pressure from top Democrats and left-wing pundits is mounting on a presumptive Biden administration to make “canceling” student debt a priority (aka, make taxpayers pay it off). The problems with this policy are endless, from its regressive benefits that skew toward the wealthiest citizens to its creation of a moral hazard problem that would encourage future students to make poor decisions.

But in a fascinating twist, a new analysis shows that even from a progressive economic perspective, student loan cancellation would be an awful economic “stimulus” policy. Left-wing advocates have made their case, in part, based on the notion that canceling student loans would free up money for people and encourage spending, which, under “Keynesian” economic theory, stimulates the economy.

Yet the nonpartisan Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget just threw cold water on this narrative. Their new analysis explicitly shows, using progressive economic assumptions and analysis, that canceling student loans wouldn’t do much to stimulate the economy at all.

Full student debt cancellation would cost taxpayers $1.5 trillion, the group says, but it would only increase cash flow available for spending by $90 billion in 2021.

As the analysis explains, this is “because borrowers often pay back their loans over 10, 15, or even 30 years, debt cancellation will increase their available cash by only a fraction of the total loan forgiveness.”

As a result, even this analysis, friendly to progressive assumptions about the economy, finds that a massive $1.5 trillion debt cancellation initiative would only boost economic output by $115 billion to $360 billion.

It’s also possible, albeit disputed and uncertain, that beneficiaries would be taxed on their student loan relief. If so, these figures would be overestimating the increased tax burden would partially offset the already minimal benefits. Even former Obama economist Jason Furman pointed this out:

So, using this amount of taxpayer money to provide another form of stimulus, such as income tax cuts or payroll tax cuts, would do far more, even under this model, to get the economy going again.

But don’t expect this thorough debunking to halt the liberal push to cancel student debt. It’s never been about facts or reality.

The very notion of a student debt “crisis” itself is overblown in its premise. The average student loan payment is between $200 and $300. That is not a crisis — it is an inconvenience, one that responsible young adults should certainly be able to handle without offloading their debts on to working-class taxpayers.

So they’ve never had the moral high ground. Now, the Left have lost one of their main economic arguments in favor of debt cancellation.

We already knew that it isn’t “progressive” — student loan debt cancellation overwhelmingly benefits the well-off and well educated. And with this new analysis, even liberals must accept that debt cancellation won’t “stimulate the economy.” It barely increases cash flow and gives money to those least likely to spend it.

And it isn’t even in response to a genuine crisis. So, the case for “canceling” student loan debt is incredibly weak. Even if Democratic politicians knew this, they’d still push for cancellation to help young people with undergraduate degrees or higher, a key Democratic voting constituency.

Brad Polumbo (@Brad_Polumbo) is a Washington Examiner contributor and host of the Breaking Boundaries podcast.

Read More at Washingtonexaminer

Latest news

New York Times writer admits Trump was right all along when it came to reopening schools

New York Times columnist Nicholas Kristof wrote last week that President Donald Trump was right when during 2020's spring months he insisted that children...

Key Events In This Holiday-Shortened Week: PMIs, Spending, GDP And CapEx

In the holiday-shortened week ahead, the key economic data releases will be the second Q3 GDP estimate, the personal income and spending report, and...

COVID-19 deaths at LaSalle Veterans’ Home launches first pandemic public oversight hearing in Illinois

The first public oversight hearing throughout the pandemic is set for Tuesday when...

It’s time ‘to begin the full and formal transition’

Republican Sen. Lisa Murkowski believes President Trump has exhausted all of his legal options...

Related news

Unemployment benefits are the worst kind of pandemic relief

The conventional wisdom machine in Washington is spinning up one of its “everybody knows”...

A Neighbor You Like Probably Voted For Trump

One of my new neighbors in Denver ended our friendship a few days ago over what I do for a living and my vote...

5 More Ways Joe Biden Magically Outperformed Election Norms

In all the excitement among objective journalists for Joe Biden’s declared victory, reporters are missing how extraordinary the Democrat’s performance was in the 2020...

Election Fraud Is Too Important To Be Left To Conspiracy Theorists

On Friday, Trump campaign lawyer Sidney Powell told The Blaze’s Glenn Beck “our forces” have confiscated a voting company server in Germany linked to...

Will Georgia’s Two Senate Runoffs Split Different Ways?

The presidential race seems to be over. Republicans gained seats in the House, but Democratic control is assured there too, if narrowly. Only the...

After Trans Activists Try To Ban Book, It Becomes A Bestseller

It seems the battle about the rights and privileges of transgender Americans has come down to what other people are allowed to say about...

America Needs A Special Counsel To Investigate Election Integrity, Stat

Well, it’s been decided. The powers that be have declared that Joe Biden is the next president of the United States, signaling an end...