17.3 C
Houston
Friday, October 30, 2020

Betsy DeVos is right that boys can’t be girls

It’s no wonder Betsy DeVos drives the Left nuts.

As the political Left goes all atwitter about a transgender-related issue that could massively help conservatives in this fall’s elections, the Education Department under Secretary DeVos follows the law quite reasonably – but in ways that tie the Left into knots.

Witness the wedge DeVos is driving between homosexual activists and transgender agitators. It’s a wedge her department drove more deeply on Thursday night with a referral letter to the Justice Department. The letter requests a consequential investigation into seven Connecticut jurisdictions for allowing biological males to compete in girls’ sports.

Yet, lest anyone accuse DeVos and her team of anti-gay bigotry, the same department is siding with an Alabama high school girl denied a spot on a school squad specifically because she is a lesbian. One would think that would make the cultural Left happy, but no: The web site Outsports is outraged at the audacity of DeVos distinguishing between a lesbian, whose case DeVos’ team is supporting, and boys trying to compete as girls, whose cause the department is opposing.

The administration is “sending a mixed message to America’s schools,” write Outsports’ Dawn Ennis. What’s wrong, she writes, is that DeVos is “once again using that telltale phrase relied upon by bigots, TERFs, and transphobes everywhere: biological sex.” (TERF apparently stands for trans-exclusionary radical feminist. Really.)

So here we have the Left, which fancies itself the defender of science, furiously reacting against the indisputable science that there is such a thing as biological sex. Rather than being a recognition of basic reality, “biological sex” is now to be treated as a catchphrase for bigotry. Never mind the established and patently obvious fact, reconfirmed last week for purposes of the Olympics by the Swiss Supreme Court, that biological males have massively higher amounts of testosterone, and almost always significantly larger proportions of muscle mass, than females do.

Anyway, DeVos’ team for months has been advising school districts in Connecticut that their practice of allowing boys-who-identify-as-girls to compete in girls athletics is a violation of the famous Title IX rules guaranteeing female student-athletes equal treatment (including funding requirements) with male students. On August 31, it reaffirmed that conclusion, in light of questions raised by this year’s Bostock Supreme Court case creating legally actionable workplace rights for transgender people.

DeVos’ team quite rightly noted that Bostock involved Title VII of the Civil Right Act of 1964, not Title IX of the Education Act Amendments of 1972. The two provisions address entirely different subjects in entirely different ways. Indeed, the Supreme Court itself wrote in Bostock that its decision on Title VII does not “affect” unrelated federal or state laws, including those regarding issues such as “sex-segregated bathrooms, locker rooms, and dress codes.”

Facing continued intransigence to its August 31 notice from six Connecticut school districts and the state’s main athletic conference, DeVos on September 17 gave notice of her department’s referrals to the Justice Department, asking Justice for “appropriate judicial relief” against those jurisdictions. As the August notice had exhaustively detailed, the participation of biological males in girls’ sports has directly deprived several girls of spots in state championship contests and in the New England Regional Championships, materially affecting their resumés, and even ability to garner scholarships, for college – not to mention high school awards and recognition in local papers and the like.

On the other hand, DeVos’ team is intervening on behalf of the lesbian student in Alabama. Unlike biological males competing as female, the lesbian’s participation in a school color guard would confer no unfair advantage on her. Her sexual proclivities give her no extra testosterone, muscle mass, or other competitive edge. Instead, the school’s refusal to let her participate just because she “likes girls” is a rank unfairness perpetrated against her.

Leftists such as Ennis of Outsports can’t stand seeing homosexuality separated from transgenderism because it deprives the latter of political power. The differences, though, both legally and practically, are immense. They are differences that all-time-great tennis star Martina Navratilova and others have insisted upon in advocating the exact same legal distinctions DeVos is asserting this month.

Most people in the real world understand this without any problem. DeVos’ team has it right: A boy can “like” a boy and a girl can “like” a girl, but boys (past puberty) have physical attributes no surgeon can undo. It is decidedly unfair, and by Title IX still illegal, to force girls to compete against them.



Read More at Washingtonexaminer

Latest news

Von Greyerz: “Get Ready For The Biggest Collapse In Human History”

Authored by Egon von Greyerz via GoldSwitzerland.com,Liftoff & CollapseGet ready for the biggest collapse in the history of mankind. It will be devastating and...

Biden trashes Trump’s Cuba policy in Florida

Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden wasn't subtle in his pitch to Florida Latinos as...

The ACLU Is Suing Police Across The Country For “Brutality” In Response To Riots And Looting This Summer

In addition to having to deal with inept politicians and their respective police forces being harassed and assaulted across the U.S., cities are also...

Rapper Ice Cube says he refused group online call with Kamala Harris because it wouldn’t be ‘productive’ and just a ‘rally call’

Iconic rap artist Ice Cube said that he refused to be a part of a celebrity Zoom call with Sen. Kamala Harris (D-Calif.), the...

Related news

Will Trump’s Union Inroads Send Him To The White House One More Time?

On this episode of The Federalist Radio Hour, The Federalist’s Senior Editor Christopher Bedford and New York Correspondent David Marcus discuss their time on...

FBI Actively Investigating ‘Hunter Biden And His Associates’ For Money-Laundering

The Department of Justice took the rare step to confirm the existence of an ongoing investigation Thursday, confirming to Sinclair that the FBI is...

Trump’s smashing court success and other commentary

Conservative: Trump’s Smashing Court Success With Amy Coney Barrett’s confirmation, President Trump is now clearly “the most important president in the modern era when it...

The Vatican’s just-renewed agreement with China follows an ancient pattern

It’s the last full week of presidential campaigning, so Americans might be excused for having missed news that the Vatican renewed its preliminary agreement...

NBC News anchor covers for Joe Biden’s anti-vaxxer rhetoric

NBC News's Andrea Mitchell insists the 2020 Democratic ticket has not used anti-vaxxer rhetoric...

Trump Admin Stops Iran From Sending Terrorists More Guns And Oil

Multiple U.S. federal agencies are taking action against Iran for illegally transferring weapons and oil to “countries that pose grave threats to the security...

Trending News

White House Blocks CDC ‘No Sail’ Order

The Centers for Disease...

Rasmussen poll says 46% of black voters approve of President Trump

A daily tracking poll of President Donald Trump's job approval released Friday showed an eye-popping surge in approval for Trump among black voters. According...

DHS pushes back on reports lawyers can’t find parents of children separated at border

A Department of Homeland Security spokesman pushed back against a news story claiming that...

Joe Biden Boasts Of ‘Most Extensive’ Voter Fraud ‘In The History Of American Politics’

Democratic Presidential Nominee Joe Biden recently bragged that Democrats have created the “most extensive and inclusive voter fraud organization in the history of American...

Former never-Trumper James Lindsay on why he just CAN’T vote for Joe Biden

This is a moment "Cynical Theories" author James Lindsay probably hoped would never come. The liberal mathematician and host of the "New Discourses Podcast"...

Secret Service Travel Logs Match Details in Alleged Hunter Biden Emails

Secret Service logs obtained earlier this year by Senate investigators include dates and locations matching those discussed in the emails allegedly belonging to Hunter...

Cycle Threshold Value Missing in CCP Virus Case Numbers: Experts

News Analysis Since the beginning of the CCP (Chinese Communist Party) virus pandemic, policymakers in the United States have relied heavily on the daily positive cases—confirmed by...

Joe Biden was the “Big Guy” Getting 10% of the Deal With Chinese Businessman Says Insider

  Among the second set of documents released by the New York Post last week were emails involving two different business schemes Hunter Biden is...