25.4 C
Friday, October 23, 2020

Critics argue Medicare’s payment structure impedes healthcare productivity

Why is the healthcare sector in the United States less productive than other sectors of our economy?

Brian Blase, the head of Blase Policy Strategies and senior fellow at the conservative Galen Institute, argues that Medicare’s method of paying for healthcare plays a large role.

“A new medical technology may do what patients want: lower costs and improve technology, but it will struggle to get properly reimbursed by Medicare,” Blase said.

This could be particularly problematic as computer technology advances in healthcare. Recently, the Food and Drug Administration approved an autonomous artificial intelligence test for diabetic retinopathy. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, the agency that decides what Medicare will pay for, is currently trying to determine how much it will pay for an AI exam.

Diabetic retinopathy is a diabetes-related disease that causes damage to the blood vessels in the eye and can result in a severe loss of vision. Catching it earlier can minimize the damage. Currently, most exams for diabetic retinopathy are performed by ophthalmologists. An AI test would enable such exams to be performed in primary care offices as well, thereby expanding access to such exams. It is also more accurate than a manual exam and less expensive. Yet Medicare may prevent the healthcare sector from gaining the improved productivity that comes with an AI test for diabetic retinopathy.

The productivity of any sector of the economy is the amount of inputs, such as labor and time, required to produce an amount of input. A healthy economy is one in which productivity improves over time, in which the amount of inputs needed to produce outputs declines. According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, labor productivity in the U.S. economy grew by an average annual rate of 2.1% from 2000 to 2017. By contrast, labor productivity in the hospital sector declined by about 0.2% while productivity at diagnostic imaging centers grew by only 0.2%.

The problem, Blase said, is the methodology CMS uses to determine prices.

“They reimburse based on a physician’s time and skill,” he said. “If a technology comes along that makes what a physician does obsolete … it doesn’t fit in with how [CMS] sets its payments.”

The methodology CMS uses to determine what Medicare will pay for a medical procedure estimates the amount of labor that a physician puts into that procedure. The more labor that a physician puts into a procedure, the higher the price that CMS will set for the procedure. This discourages physicians and other healthcare providers from finding ways to reduce the amount of labor that goes into providing healthcare since they get paid more for procedures and services that require greater labor.

In a market in which government does not set prices, producers compete on price. To attract more customers, producers must lower their prices. This incentivizes them to reduce the amount of labor that goes into producing goods and services since lower labor costs enable them to charge lower prices.

Eyenuk Inc. has developed an AI test for diabetic retinopathy and wants to charge $55 for an exam. That would be cheaper than the $187 that Medicare currently pays for an ophthalmologist to do the exam. But because CMS factors physician labor into its prices and an AI test involves little labor, the agency has proposed letting Medicare pay $11.

On the surface, it would seem Medicare would pay even less for diabetic retinopathy exams. But if CMS sets the price too low, then physicians and other healthcare providers will be slow to adopt the newer and cheaper AI technology. Medicare will continue paying for more costly exams by ophthalmologists longer than it would otherwise.

Of course, not everyone agrees that Medicare’s payment system is what harms productivity in the U.S. healthcare system.

Maura Calsyn, managing director of health policy at the liberal Center for American Progress, said that Blase “assumes that market-based prices are preferable to Medicare prices. Medicare is a better value for taxpayers than private plans, so terms like ‘productivity’ and ‘innovation’ are missing that broader point.”

Sophia Tripoli, director of healthcare innovations at the liberal Families USA, argued that higher costs in the U.S. healthcare system aren’t a result of poor productivity.

“[Higher] prices are the result of highly consolidated healthcare markets and members of healthcare industry battling for relative market power to negotiate prices,” she said. “There is now overwhelming evidence that current market rates in healthcare are highly distorted and that increased market consolidation leads to high healthcare prices, which is the driver of the U.S. healthcare cost crisis.”

Nevertheless, if Medicare’s payment system causes the healthcare system to adopt AI more slowly, it will prove costly for both the healthcare system and individuals with diabetes. As a result of its inability to improve productivity, the healthcare system accounts for an ever growing percentage of the nation’s economy. In 2000, healthcare accounted for 13% of the gross domestic product. By 2019, it was 17.8%.

And greater access to an AI test could greatly improve outcomes for people with diabetes, perhaps lowering long-term costs from diabetic retinopathy. An estimated 7.7 million people had diabetic retinopathy in 2010, and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention projects that could increase to over 14 million by 2050. Indeed, the primary beneficiaries of Medicare, seniors age 65 and older, seem to be in need of greater access to eye exams. An estimated 14.4 million people age 65 and older have diabetes, but 46% of them do not have an annual eye exam.

Read More at Washingtonexaminer

Latest news

This is the President Trump we should have seen weeks ago: Goodwin

The best Trump ever. That’s what America saw in Thursday’s debate as the president finally found his stride. He was substantive, measured and relatively calm...

Biggest lie of the night? Joe Biden says no one lost their health insurance under Obamacare

Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden told a brazen lie about Obamacare Thursday evening during the final presidential debate in Nashville, Tennessee, claiming that no...

Joe Biden says Hunter Biden laptop story is ‘Russian plan’ despite lack of evidence

During Thursday’s presidential debate, Joe Biden dismissed purported emails from a laptop belonging...

Yes, Joe Biden absolutely said he opposes fracking

Democratic nominee Joe Biden is lying. ...

Related news

Joe Biden revived Obama’s most infamous lie

Struggling to explain the details of his own healthcare plan to voters at Thursday...

Healthcare facilities scramble to stock up on personal protective equipment

As a third surge of the coronavirus pandemic threatens Midwestern states that were...

FDA commits to high safety standards in coronavirus vaccine review

The Food and Drug Administration’s coronavirus vaccine advisory panel assured the public that...

Majority of voters say coronavirus is ‘out of control’ in the US: Poll

Most voters believe that the coronavirus pandemic is currently “out of control” in...

CDC Ponders Shorter Quarantines for Children

The Centers for Disease...

Trending News

VIDEO: In July, a Minnesota Democratic candidate tried to blow the whistle after witnessing ‘worse than Somalia’ voter fraud

A few thousand votes in swing-state Minnesota may decide November's presidential election.In recent years, multiple Somali-Americans living in Minneapolis-St. Paul have come forward to...

Secret Service Travel Logs Match Details in Alleged Hunter Biden Emails

Secret Service logs obtained earlier this year by Senate investigators include dates and locations matching those discussed in the emails allegedly belonging to Hunter...

Black Veteran Says His Vote for Trump Is ‘Solidified’ After Rioters Fire Gun at His Cafe

A black Portland business owner and military veteran says his plans to cast his vote in the upcoming presidential race for President Donald Trump...

Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer Vetoes Bill Targeting Voter Fraud

Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer (D) vetoed legislation that would have made it a felony to attempt to apply for multiple absentee ballots or fill...

China Ties to US Riots Exposed by Trevor Loudon

Most of the riots that racked the United States within the last few months were organized by two socialist organizations which have close ties...

The FBI Seized the Hunter Biden Computer in December 2019

After years of leadership from the likes of Robert Mueller, James Comey and Christopher Wray, the FBI’s name is severely tarnished.  Numerous major criminal...

17-Year-Old Student Cyberbullied By Teacher and May Be Expelled for Sharing Conservative Content on Instagram

A 17-year-old student at a Virginia boarding school is facing disciplinary action for opposing Black Lives Matter and posting mainstream conservative content on Instagram. Mackenzie...

Rep. Doug Collins Announces Resolution to Remove Pelosi as Speaker

Rep. Doug Collins (R-Ga.) said on Monday that he is introducing a resolution calling for the removal of Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) as house speaker,...