17.3 C
Thursday, January 21, 2021

Elderly And Disabled People Should Not Be Last For COVID Care

When the Titanic sank in 1912, the captain famously ordered women and children be loaded first onto the precious few lifeboats. While the code of chivalry may have changed in the ensuing decades, the need to plan for the unthinkable has not.

The ongoing surge in COVID-19 cases is forcing hospitals to face the awful question of who will receive life-saving care and who will be denied if resources run out. How we respond to this moment, especially to the most vulnerable among us, will be a reflection and test of our national character.

As the director of the Office for Civil Rights at the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, I tasked my colleagues with reviewing state triage and emergency hospital rationing plans — known as Crisis Standards of Care — after receiving several complaints from advocates early during the pandemic. We were shocked to find instances of blatant discrimination against people with disabilities and older Americans in these plans.

One state, using archaic language to refer to persons with intellectual disabilities, would have flatly excluded people with “profound mental retardation” from being given ventilators. Other states placed persons with disabilities or older adults at the end of the line for treatment based on uncertain judgments about long-term life expectancy or the number of resources a person might consume in the process of saving their lives. Many people with disabilities justifiably feared having ventilators taken away from them to be given to others judged more “worthy.”

- Advertisement -

Working with state authorities, civil rights advocates, and health experts, we have helped states shift from reliance on categorical exclusions from care based on age or disability to the criteria of the likelihood of survival to hospital discharge. We have shifted the focus of state plans from treating patients as statistics to treating them as individuals with a right to be free from judgments based on stereotypes or overbroad and irrelevant generalizations.

We have also made clear that clinically relevant factors may be considered insofar as they do not rely on speculative judgments regarding future long-term survival, duration of need, or measures of relative “worth.” A growing number of states are also making clear that reallocating personal ventilators is unacceptable. We commend the state of Utah and the National Academy of Medicine in particular for working with my office to adopt Crisis Standard of Care plans and guidelines that embody the best civil rights practices.

Finally, my office has been extremely clear that judgments regarding quality of life should never be used to decide who receives access to care. For too long, people with disabilities and older persons have worried about being devalued by the medical system. Imposed judgments regarding which lives are worth living, and thus worthy of saving, corrupt the practice of medicine and erode our nation’s dearest held values.

Only patients or their authorized representatives should decide whether they wish to decline or consent to the withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment. Pressure from providers to change their minds based on their disability and age is not only unethical, it may also be illegal.

This work is part of larger efforts my office has undertaken to protect civil rights during the pandemic by ensuring minority communities — including those with limited English proficiency — have access to testing and vaccines without unlawful barriers, and by ensuring hospital patients with physical, psychological, or spiritual challenges get physical access to necessary support persons and to clergy in their time of greatest need.

These efforts reflect our fundamental commitment to equity, respect for life, and non-discrimination for all Americans under law. We are proud of what we have accomplished to unite people from the left, middle, and right around the principle of respect for human dignity during this crisis.

We recognize that providers may have to make hard choices in the coming days, but we must hold fast to our core values and remain committed to our civil rights laws, even in times of emergency, because that is often when we need them most. As we pray that rationing of care never comes to any hospital in any state, we must prepare nonetheless, starting with the premise that every life is equally precious.

Roger Severino is the Director of the Office for Civil Rights at the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services and works in Washington, D.C.

Read more at Thefederalist

Latest news

Trump wants to start a new political party?

it was reported yesterday that Trump has already begun talking about creating a new political party called the ‘Patriot Party’: WSJ – President Trump has...

Michigan governor travels to DC for Biden’s inauguration after urging residents to stay home during holidays

Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer traveled to President Biden’s inauguration in the nation’s capital after...

Biden admin faced day one controversy over change to US ambassador to Israel Twitter account

The Biden administration on Wednesday stirred controversy on day one by temporarily changing the Twitter account for the U.S. Ambassador to Israel before reversing...

Niskanen Center VP Calls For Execution Of Mike Pence By Lynching

While Democrats were obsessing over potential violence from Trump supporters on Inauguration Day, leftist think tank vice president and New York Times contributor Will...

Related news

Niskanen Center VP Calls For Execution Of Mike Pence By Lynching

While Democrats were obsessing over potential violence from Trump supporters on Inauguration Day, leftist think tank vice president and New York Times contributor Will...

Biden’s team is once again lowering expectations for its pandemic response

The lowering of expectations continues. ...

Inauguration Violence Erupts… From Antifa And The Left

As Washington, D.C., and federal officials around the country geared up for what many wrongly predicted would be an insurrection by Trump supporters on...

Biden must follow through on the State Department’s China genocide declaration

On his last full day in office, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo formally declared...

Dems Rally To Purge ‘Extremists’ And Trump Voters From National Guard

Following the Capitol riot on Jan. 6, Democrats are now calling for and encouraging the vetting of National Guard members, especially those assigned to...

How Joe Biden Misunderstands Unity

Yesterday’s remarks from Joe Biden were what we thought they would be: a lot of talk about unity, and a lot of condemnations of...

Day One, Biden Destroys Girls’ Sports With Anti-Science Executive Order

President Joe Biden issued an executive order on his first day in office, mandating that any schools that receive federal funding must function as...

Within hours of calling for unity, Biden smashes norms to reward Big Labor

President Biden made an impassioned call for unity in an inaugural address that was...