23.6 C
Houston
Saturday, September 19, 2020

Germany, Denmark Are Models For How To Reopen Schools In The Age Of COVID-19

With the fall semester officially starting this week in some parts of the US, the question of how public schools will reopen for the fall semester, and how much in-person learning to allow, if any, is weighing on the minds of millions of Americans.

 

And while we await to learn more about New York’s plans for reopening its schools, a team of economists at Goldman Sachs took a close look at the existing data surrounding the virus’s ability to spread in schools, and among younger children, along with the economic costs of keeping schools closed, in an attempt to answer a critical question: How exactly should the US go about reopening its schools?

Looking at the problem from a strictly medical perspective is difficult enough. The research that exists is often contradictory. One large study based on comprehensive contact tracing in South Korea found that children under 10 were roughly half as likely as adults to transmit the virus to others, while children between the ages of 10 and 19 transmitted the virus at similar rates to adults.

Other studies appear to show children spreading the virus at similar rates to adults, including one study focusing on a summer camp in Georgia.

Another study found that children may carry higher viral loads, suggesting that they could put adults around them at high risk of infection. 

It’s fair to assume at this point that children are at less risk of infection and death, but that’s about all we can say for sure. As always, the bigger problem is what are the societal ramifications in terms of infection numbers?

The usefulness of these studies is clearly limited. With that in mind, governments should instead look to the handful of examples where schools successfully have reopened without triggering the virus to come roaring back.

We’ve repeatedly cited the experience of Denmark as a potential guiding light for the US, and the rest of Europe, when it comes to reopening schools. Goldman takes this analysis a few steps further, looking at an even broader scope of countries that have reopened schools cautiously and carefully, despite having only limited numbers of the infected.

Still, Belgium, France and Germany certainly saw substantial outbreaks, even if the virus may not have penetrated as deeply, in as many parts of their countries, as it did in the US.

American states could probably learn a thing or two from the judicious approach favored by Germany, France and Belgium. And if that isn’t enough to drive home the point, Goldman argues that Israel’s approach stands in stark contrast to Europe: Israel reopened classes with as many as 40 students, and few restrictions. Cases quickly flared back up, suggesting that reopening must be carefully monitored.

Here’s a more detailed breakdown of how various countries approached reopening their schools.

Sweden, as Goldman points out, never closed its schools. And although it’s not a focus of the report, its example certainly warrants close scrutiny.

To be sure, the process of reopening schools in the US will require a much more detailed explanation. Approaches will vary widely from state to state, with Georgia, Indiana and a handful of other states pushing ahead with the return to in-person instruction, even as cases from the outbreak’s second wave have only just begun to decline.

But motivated by the second wave and parents’ lingering fears, a growing number of states are pushing back start dates for in-person learning. Some states have left the decision up to individual counties – and some counties like Miami-Dade have been steadfast in their opposition to pressure from the statehouse and Washington.

In many cases, local school districts will decide when to reopen.

Like with many other aspects of the government response to the pandemic, keeping schools closed places the biggest strain on the most vulnerable members of society, especially single parents…

…but also married couples. Regardless, without schools open, a large chunk of the labor force will require support in the form of child care to make a return to full-time work plausible.

 

While keeping schools closed comes with a tremendous economic pricetag, since not only are educators out of work, but parents, too, struggle to secure affordable childcare, putting their jobs at risk. This can seriously suppress productivity and labor-market growth. But in the worst-hit states, the risks of thousands of preventable deaths are simply too great to justify pressing ahead.

Successfully reopening schools will ultimately depend less on infection rates among students, but on infection rates among parents, teachers and coaches.

Zerohedge

Latest news

Putin foe Alexei Navalny shares picture of himself walking a month after suspected poisoning

Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny posted a photo of himself walking a month...

“It’s Time To Lighten Exposure”: Here Are The Next Four Risks For Markets

September's big event for markets - the FOMC meeting - has come and gone and clearly there was some disappointment in markets from a...

Black Lives Matter activist admits to not being actually black

Satchuel Cole, a prominent Black Lives Matter in Indiana, has apologized for misleading...

Reward doubled for tips on suspects who targeted Camden cops

Authorities have more than doubled the reward for information on the three suspects who shot up the home of two married Camden County Police...

Related news

Putin foe Alexei Navalny shares picture of himself walking a month after suspected poisoning

Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny posted a photo of himself walking a month...

“It’s Time To Lighten Exposure”: Here Are The Next Four Risks For Markets

September's big event for markets - the FOMC meeting - has come and gone and clearly there was some disappointment in markets from a...

Black Lives Matter activist admits to not being actually black

Satchuel Cole, a prominent Black Lives Matter in Indiana, has apologized for misleading...

Governments Will Impose New Lockdowns If They Think They Can Get Away With It

Authored by Ryan McMaken via The Mises Institute, This year’s stay-at-home orders and lockdowns imposed by governments on their populations represent a watershed moment in...

‘Five seconds of unity’ – Surreal Vid of moment Trump was told about RBG is already ICONIC, and the TALK of Twitter

The very moment that President Donald Trump was told about the death of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg was on camera, as a reporter told...

‘We Were Put in This Position’

News Alex Brandon / APPresident Donald Trump speaks during a news conference in the James Brady Press Briefing Room of the White House on Sept....

Rioters Threaten to Report Apartment Dweller to Management for Egging Mob

The Portland riots resumed Friday night after taking a break for a few days on the pretense of the West Coast wildfires to recover...

Picking RBG’s Successor: The Who & The When

Picking RBG's Successor: The Who & The When Tyler Durden Sat, 09/19/2020 - 12:25 ...