27.1 C
Houston
Tuesday, July 14, 2020

Gordon Johnson: Warranty Accounting Impropriety At Tesla Similar To Accounting At Wirecard

- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -

Right around the same time that Tesla was leaking to electrek that the company could break even in Q2 despite the pandemic, analyst Gordon Johnson of GLJ Research was putting his clients on notice about “continued deception” and “accounting impropriety” that is “similar” to Wirecard.

Of course, the stock responded on Tuesday to only one of these two reports, surging higher on the back of Musk’s comments and a continued gamma squeeze helped along by multi-million dollar sweeps of $1500 and $1800 calls on Monday. 

Options data via @CheddarFlow

Regardless, Johnson’s note about Tesla’s warranty accounting talks about serious issues that eventually may not be able to be ignored. Johnson estimates on Monday that Tesla has recognized just $1,427 per car in warranty reserves versus the $3,308 per car that it should. This has led to a gross profit overstatement of $148.93 million, according to Johnson:

If you take TSLA’s adjusted warranty reserve in 1Q20 of $78.95mn and divide by its adjusted aggregate cars on the road of 763,755, you arrive at a number of $103.37/car; thus, given TSLA provides an 8-yr battery/motor warranty, and thus every car sold is still under warranty, $103.37/car x 32 = $3,308/car of lifetime expense x 79,200 cars sold and on the road in 1Q20 = the amount TSLA should have taken in 1Q20 pre-adjustment warranty provision (~$275mn) ; yet, taking the adjusted 1Q20 warranty provision of $119mn vs. 79,200 cars on the road, TSLA recognized just $1,427/car in reserves in 1Q20.

So ($3,308/car x 79,200 cars on the road) – ($1,427/car x 79,200 cars on the road) = gross profit overstatement of $148.932mn. This is a pretty big deal, and not only overstates gross margin, but also overstates net income – see below for TSLA classifying warranty cost as “goodwill”.

Johnson then posted several examples of the company accounting for warranty costs as goodwill, thus artificially boosting its gross margin and net income.

Interestingly, Johnson also noted last week that Tesla’s end of quarter push didn’t seem to be going well, which contradicts what has apparently been leaked to electrek. Johnson noted that Florida and Texas were very important markets to monitor since they were the closest to “real-time” of any U.S. Tesla data sets. New York and California, he noted, were 1-2 months behind. 

Johnson noted the following trends last week:

  • OVERALL THIS WEEK (i.e., the most important week for TSLA’s 2Q20 numbers): Model 3 slowing in FL; Model Y slowing in FL; Model Y slowing in TX; Model 3 accelerating, slightly, in TX.
  • FLORIDA THIS WEEK (i.e., the most important week for TSLA’s 2Q20 numbers): Last week TSLA was averaging 54 3+Y/day; this week, so far, it’s 40.
  • TEXAS THIS WEEK (i.e., the most important week for TSLA’s 2Q20 numbers): Last week TSLA was averaging 36 3+Y/day; this week, so far, it’s 39 (the data come in much stronger than expected today – the strength is 100% from the Model 3).

Johnson concluded that “the end-of-quarter push is the weakest it’s been since they ran out of cars in 4Q19 (unlike then, however, this time they have a record level of inventory)”.

And for those note familiar with accounting who still want the gist of Johnson’s note, we’ll refer you to this Tweet, which popped up yesterday:

 



Zerohedge

- Advertisement -

Latest news

- Advertisement -

Russia-led Nord Stream 2 Gas Pipeline Could Be Completed Soon

Authored by Tsvetana Paraskova via OilPrice.com, A Russian vessel capable of completing the pipelaying for the Gazprom-led Nord Stream 2 natural gas pipeline project left...

German Sex Workers Demand Right To Work Amid COVID 

German Health Minister Jens Spahn warned Monday that "the threat of a second virus wave is real." Although COVID-19 infection numbers in Europe's largest economy were relatively low, Spahn...

Stocks up as Market Faces Down Latest Hurdle: Dismal Profits

NEW YORK—Here comes the latest hurdle for the pandemic-defying stock market to leap with ease, investors hope: the worst quarter for profit growth in...

Related news

Russia-led Nord Stream 2 Gas Pipeline Could Be Completed Soon

Authored by Tsvetana Paraskova via OilPrice.com, A Russian vessel capable of completing the pipelaying for the Gazprom-led Nord Stream 2 natural gas pipeline project left...

German Sex Workers Demand Right To Work Amid COVID 

German Health Minister Jens Spahn warned Monday that "the threat of a second virus wave is real." Although COVID-19 infection numbers in Europe's largest economy were relatively low, Spahn...

Stocks up as Market Faces Down Latest Hurdle: Dismal Profits

NEW YORK—Here comes the latest hurdle for the pandemic-defying stock market to leap with ease, investors hope: the worst quarter for profit growth in...

Fire Still Burning on Navy Ship in San Diego Where 57 Hurt

SAN DIEGO—Firefighters were still battling a blaze on July 13 on a Navy combat ship that injured at least 57 people and sent acrid...

Assad Sends Pantsir Air Defense Systems To Counter Turkey In Libya

Submitted by SouthFront, The Syrian government seems to be deploying Pantsir-S1 air defense systems to Libya to assist forces of Field Marshal Khalifa Haftar in...

Tucker Carlson Announces “Long Planned” Vacation After CNN Report Takes Out Top Show Writer Over Racist Posts

Top rated Fox News Channel host Tucker Carlson announced a “long planned” trout fishing vacation Monday night after a senior writer on his show...

Former MythBusters Host Grant Imahara Dies Suddenly At 49

A former host of popular science show “Mythbusters,” Grant Imahara, has died suddenly at the age of 49. According to The Hollywood Report, Imahara died...

Concorde 2.0? Boom Supersonic To Unveil Ultrafast Plane In October 

It's been 17 years since Aerospatiale/BAC Concorde, a turbojet-powered supersonic passenger airliner, flew passengers across the Atlantic at Mach 2.04 (1,341 mph). Come October, that could all change, as Boom...
- Advertisement -