19.7 C
Houston
Sunday, November 1, 2020

Judge Declines to Allow Pennsylvania Governor to Reimpose Limits on Gatherings

A Pennsylvania judge on Tuesday said he would not let Gov. Tom Wolf reimpose limits on gatherings.

U.S. District Judge William Stickman IV ruled that Wolf administration officials didn’t succeed in demonstrating they’re likely to prevail on appeal.

Stickman, a Trump appointee, ruled last week that Wolf’s restrictions ordering people to stay at home and limit gatherings were unconstitutional.

The Constitution “cannot accept the concept of a ‘new normal’ where the basic liberties of the people can be subordinated to open-ended emergency mitigation measures,” he wrote at the time.

Wolf sought a stay of the ruling, but Stickman said his administration didn’t present information that would warrant a stay.

The primary focus of the stay request was the determination that the imposition of number limits on gatherings violated the First Amendment.

Stickman noted that he didn’t say the government could not impose limitations on gatherings, but that the First Amendment doesn’t permit specific numeric caps on some gatherings while imposing a limitation based on general occupancy on others.

“Defendants did not adduce any evidence that would explain and justify treating social, cultural, political, and other similar gatherings differently from the commercial gatherings covered by a percentage of occupancy-based limitation,” the judge wrote in the new 15-page ruling.

“For example, nobody explained why hundreds may gather indoors to shop (the larger the facility, the more people permitted), dozens may dine in a restaurant (again, the larger the restaurant, the more will be permitted), but no more than twenty-five may attend an indoor lecture, a speech or a wedding.”

Nicolette Holness of Bismarck, N.D., takes a selfie while visiting Gettysburg, Penn., on Aug. 11, 2020. (Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)

Wolf, a Democrat, told reporters on Tuesday that he plans on appealing Stickman’s ruling to the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.

“Since the stay was turned down, then it sounds like, at least for the moment, I guess that court ruling stands,” he said, when asked whether gatherings of 500 are now legal.

“You ought to be careful when you get together. And if you get together in bigger and bigger numbers, you’re leaving yourself open to bigger and bigger likelihood that you’re going to catch the disease,” he added.

Pennsylvania Health Director Rachel Levine said such gatherings were not okay.

“It’s not okay. There are consequences to people’s actions,” Levine added.

Wolf’s mandates were made amid the COVID-19 pandemic. COVID-19 is a disease caused by the CCP (Chinese Communist Party) virus, which is believed to spread through close contact and severely affects a small percentage of patients.

Before the ruling earlier this month, Pennsylvania officials had said crowds of over 25 inside and 250 outside weren’t allowed.

Theepochtimes

Latest news

Trump Supporters Fill Streets of Beverly Hills: ‘The Silent Majority is Silenced No More’

The final MAGA rally transpired in Beverly Hills, California on Saturday as thousands of Trump supporters gathered three days ahead of the 2020 presidential...

Watch Live: Donald Trump Hosts a Campaign Rally in Montoursville, PA

President Donald Trump on Saturday will host a campaign rally in Montoursville, Pennsylvania.The rally is scheduled for 8:15 p.m. EST.The president is barnstorming the...

Nearly 50% Of BLM Protesters Arrested In Seattle Were White, From Other Cities

An analysis of 95 arrest records from Seattle riots from May reveals that nearly half of all suspects are white are white men from...

Related news

Nearly 50% Of BLM Protesters Arrested In Seattle Were White, From Other Cities

An analysis of 95 arrest records from Seattle riots from May reveals that nearly half of all suspects are white are white men from...

What’s Happened To Bitcoin Since Its Whitepaper Appeared 12 Years Ago?

Authored by Robert Stevens via Decrypt.io,In briefOn October 31, 2008, Satoshi Nakamoto published the Bitcoin whitepaper. Since then, Bitcoin's journey has taken in highs and...

Large US Early Voting Surge as Trump, Biden Make Late Push

A record 90 million Americans have voted early in the U.S. presidential election, data on Saturday showed, as President Donald Trump and his Democratic...

Former James Bond Actor Sean Connery Dies Aged 90

Scottish movie legend Sean Connery, who shot to international stardom as the suave, sexy and sophisticated British agent James Bond and went on to...

Trump edges out Biden in Iowa in gold-standard poll

President Trump has pulled ahead of Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden in Iowa three...

“A Lot Of People Are Leaving”: COVID Shutdowns Have Turned San Francisco Into A Ghost Town

San Francisco has managed to curb the virus slightly in its city - but at what cost? Those paying sky high taxes to live...

Bernie Sanders endorses Sarah Iannarone for Portland mayor

Far-left Portland mayoral candidate Sarah Iannarone, who has described herself as an "everyday anti-fascist" and declared, "I am Antifa," has received a huge endorsement...

Christians Worldwide Mark International Day of Prayer for the Persecuted Church

Millions of Christians worldwide will unite on Sunday, Nov. 1 to join the global body of Christ for the 2020 International Day of Prayer...

Trending News

White House Blocks CDC ‘No Sail’ Order

The Centers for Disease...

Rasmussen poll says 46% of black voters approve of President Trump

A daily tracking poll of President Donald Trump's job approval released Friday showed an eye-popping surge in approval for Trump among black voters. According...

WATCH: BLM Protesters Target Jews in Philadelphia While Yelling ‘Synagogue of Satan’

Rioters in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, targeted a group of Jews at protests Tuesday evening against the police shooting of an armed black man, calling them...

High Potency Marijuana, Psychosis, and Suicide: Johnny Stack’s Story

DENVER—It’s a grief that’s unimaginable. Deep, raw, and ever present. Laura and John Stack are still reeling over the loss of their son to...

Former never-Trumper James Lindsay on why he just CAN’T vote for Joe Biden

This is a moment "Cynical Theories" author James Lindsay probably hoped would never come. The liberal mathematician and host of the "New Discourses Podcast"...

Twitter suspends Border Patrol chief’s account for ‘hateful conduct’ over praising border wall

Twitter suspended the account belonging to U.S. Customs and Border Protection Commissioner Mark Morgan...

UPS Locates Joe Biden-Related Documents That Tucker Carlson Said Were Lost

Delivery giant UPS confirmed Thursday it found a lost trove of documents that Fox News’ Tucker Carlson said would provide revelations in the ever-growing...

Joe Biden Boasts Of ‘Most Extensive’ Voter Fraud ‘In The History Of American Politics’

Democratic Presidential Nominee Joe Biden recently bragged that Democrats have created the “most extensive and inclusive voter fraud organization in the history of American...