25.2 C
Friday, September 18, 2020

New evidence key to charges in Nebraska protester’s death

OMAHA, Neb. (AP) – This week’s decision to charge a white bar owner who fatally shot a Black man during a chaotic night of protests in downtown Omaha months after the shooting was deemed self-defense highlights how difficult it can be to sort out these cases.

The key difference in the Omaha case is that the grand jury that reviewed the case had additional evidence about what happened before surveillance video showed Jake Gardner shooting 22-year-old James Scurlock on May 30 after the two scuffled. In at least one other instance of violence during protests this year, authorities are still trying to sort out what happened.

In Minnesota, 43-year-old Calvin Horton Jr. was fatally shot near a Minneapolis pawn shop on May 27 as protests over George Floyd’s death began to turn violent. The pawn shop’s owner was arrested the night of the shooting but released several days later, with prosecutors saying they needed more information about what happened before the shooting to consider charges. Horton’s family complained in July of getting little information on the case. Hennepin County attorney’s office spokeswoman Lacey Severins said Wednesday the case remains under investigation.

“It can often be hard to sort out,” Fordham University law professor Jim Cohen said about crimes during protests. “It’s often not so easy to sort out who is unlawfully protesting – meaning looting, for example – and who is lawfully protesting.”

Those two shootings happened as protests and civil unrest has roiled cities across the country over Floyd’s May 25 death at the hands of Minneapolis police. Floyd, who was Black and handcuffed, died after a white police officer, Derek Chauvin, pressed his knee into Floyd’s neck for several minutes even after Floyd stopped moving and pleading for air.

In Omaha, Douglas County Attorney Don Kleine initially decided Gardner, the bar owner, acted in self-defense after he reviewed video of the incident and witness statements in the days after the shooting, but he asked the grand jury to examine the case after his decision was criticized because he wanted people to have faith in the justice system.

On Tuesday, Special Prosecutor Frederick Franklin said that additional evidence from Gardner’s phone and his Facebook Messenger account, along with video from inside his bar, shed light on his intent the night of the shooting. He said the new evidence undermines the self-defense theory although he wouldn’t provide specifics of exactly what it showed.

Gardner was charged with manslaughter, attempted assault, making terroristic threats and using a gun to commit a felony. His attorney, Stu Dornan, didn’t respond to phone messages from The Associated Press on Wednesday. Legal experts say prosecutors may have a difficult time securing a conviction because the case will hinge on what both men intended to do that night.

“Obviously the video tape evidence is going to be crucial in trying to determine whether or not Gardner believed that his life or his person were in grave danger under the circumstances,” said longtime Nebraska criminal attorney Clarence Mock, who has also served as a special prosecutor before.

The shooting happened outside Gardner’s bar in downtown Omaha as he sought to ward off any theft or property damage. In June, officials played surveillance video that seemed to show words exchanged between Gardner, his father and protesters after the windows of his bar were broken. Gardner flashed the gun but then backed away. Gardner was shoved to the ground by two people before he fired two shots, sending people scrambling. Scurlock then jumped on Gardner’s back and was shot by Gardner. While there was no audio with the video, Kleine said Gardner warned Scurlock to get off of him several times before he fired the fatal shot.

Creighton University law school professor Raneta Mack said determining whether Scurlock was trying to stop Gardner from hurting anyone or whether he was trying to harm Gardner could be key in the case.

“If Mr. Scurlock was coming to the defense of his friends or even members of the general public and that is why he was grabbing Gardner and putting him into a chokehold, then Gardner does not have a right of self defense,” said Mack, who has taught criminal law for nearly three decades.

But Cohen said this will be a tough case for prosecutors because jurors tend to give defendants some benefit of the doubt when they were facing a chaotic situation.

“There is a deference accorded to those who are perceived by a jury as lawfully protecting their property,” Cohen said.

Of course, more evidence will be needed at trial to prove Gardner is guilty than what is required at this stage in the process. But the fact that Gardner has been charged means that the community will be able to learn more about what happened that night. Scurlock’s death inspired protests in Omaha in the days after prosecutors initially declined to file charges.

“This will allow people to understand how the system works and be able to see for themselves what evidence the prosecution has and what evidence the defense presents to have maybe a greater understanding about what happened during the night of Mr. Scurlock’s death,” Mock said.

Copyright © 2020 The Washington Times, LLC.


Latest news

WATCH: The View goes OFF THE RAILS when Kimberly Klacik calls out Behar for wearing blackface

The View had Baltimore’s Kimberly Klacik on the show today but it went completely off the rails when she called out Joy Behar for...

Support For BLM Falls Further; Americans See “Protests” As Riots, Believe There Is A War On Police

Authored by Steve Watson via Summit News, A series of new polls reveals that the majority of Americans believe there is a war being waged...

Trump Admin Announces TikTok and WeChat Will Be Banned From US App Stores

President Donald Trump’s administration confirmed plans to ban the mobile applications TikTok and WeChat from United States’ mobile app stores. U.S. Commerce Secretary Wilbur...

Related news

Florida parents get high, drink during kids’ online classes

It’s a lesson in reading, writing and reefer. Florida moms and dads have been spotted smoking weed, drinking and walking around half-naked in the background...

Teen arrested, second suspect at large in shooting of AZ trooper

A teen was arrested and a second suspect is in the wind following an “ambush”-style shooting of an Arizona state trooper Thursday, authorities said. Luis...

Trump won’t attend UN General Assembly due to COVID-19

Like other world leaders during the coronavirus pandemic, President Trump will not travel to the Big Apple to attend next week’s UN General Assembly,...

Cops probe swastika cut into front yard of North Carolina home

A massive swastika was carved into the front yard of a North Carolina home belonging to a black family, authorities said. Deputies from the Onslow...