19.2 C
Houston
Monday, January 18, 2021

North Dakota Bill Would Let Censored Citizens File Lawsuits Against Facebook, Twitter

A bill proposed by Republican lawmakers in North Dakota could enable lawsuits to be filed against Twitter and Facebook by users who have seen their accounts deleted or censored.

The new bill (pdf), sponsored by six legislators, is titled, “an Act to permit civil actions against social media sites for censoring speech,” and it stipulates that websites with more than 1 million users would be “liable in a civil action for damages to the person whose speech is restricted, censored, or suppressed, and to any person who reasonably otherwise would have received the writing, speech, or publication.”

For individuals who have been censored, compensation includes “treble damages for compensatory, consequential, and incidental damages,” according to the bill.

North Dakota state Rep. Tom Kading (R), a sponsor of the bill, explained his rationale.

“It’s just wrong to ban a sitting president,” Kading told the Grand Forks Herald, adding that the proposal is meant to provide a legal tool for those who live in North Dakota. He was referring to Twitter, Facebook, YouTube, and other platforms taking action against President Donald Trump.

Kading further argued that Facebook and Twitter, namely, violate their own terms of agreement signed by users after they ban or restrict content related to politics.

Twitter’s rules stipulate that the site has “a zero tolerance policy against violent threats,” and a post can be removed if it “includes a declarative call to action that could harm a specific individual or group.” However, some critics of Twitter have argued that the firm has overstepped its bounds by creating its own definition and adds context about what “violent threats” may be, while some have highlighted double-standards around content.

Some experts said the proposed bill would not have an effect.

Attorney Akiva Cohen wrote on Twitter that the law “would immediately be deemed void as preempted by Section 230 [of the Communications Decency Act],” because “federal law is supreme over state law where they conflict, and this would create an express conflict.”

Section 230 has been criticized by conservatives as a law that essentially serves as a liability shield for Twitter and Facebook. The 1996 law states that providers and users of computer services shouldn’t be held liable for “any action voluntarily taken in good faith to restrict access to or availability of material that the provider or user considers to be obscene, lewd, lascivious, filthy, excessively violent, harassing, or otherwise objectionable, whether or not such material is constitutionally protected.”

The law gives a shield to companies that moderate user-generated content. Trump and other Republicans have said it should be repealed, arguing that Big Tech firms have essentially overstepped their bounds by moderating content.



Theepochtimes

Latest news

As goes the Biden $15 minimum wage, so should go the standard deduction

Joe Biden just said the standard deduction should be $30,000 per year per person....

‘I did nothing wrong’: Mom punched at DC rally is now out of a job, and fearful she can’t get one

Trump supporter Therese Duke was left bruised and bleeding after being punched in the face at a rally in Washington, D.C., on Jan. 5....

Lauren Boebert rebukes Democrat who suggested she gave tour to rioters before Capitol breach

Rep. Lauren Boebert issued a stinging rebuke of Democratic Rep. Steve Cohen, who suggested...

Peter Schiff: Economic “Rescue” Plan Like Throwing A Drowning Man An Anchor

Via SchiffGold.com,President-elect Joe Biden unveiled his massive stimulus plan last week touted as the “American Rescue Plan.” In his podcast, Peter Schiff said it...

Related news

‘I did nothing wrong’: Mom punched at DC rally is now out of a job, and fearful she can’t get one

Trump supporter Therese Duke was left bruised and bleeding after being punched in the face at a rally in Washington, D.C., on Jan. 5....

Lauren Boebert rebukes Democrat who suggested she gave tour to rioters before Capitol breach

Rep. Lauren Boebert issued a stinging rebuke of Democratic Rep. Steve Cohen, who suggested...

Peter Schiff: Economic “Rescue” Plan Like Throwing A Drowning Man An Anchor

Via SchiffGold.com,President-elect Joe Biden unveiled his massive stimulus plan last week touted as the “American Rescue Plan.” In his podcast, Peter Schiff said it...

Acting Secretary of Defense Christopher Miller Labels Biden Inauguration a “Large Security Event”

Secretary of Defense Christopher Miller calls the scheduled Biden Inauguration a “Large Security Event”.   Today, the US Department of Defense issued an ‘Immediate Release”...

Capitol Police failed to prep for riot despite warnings, former DHS head Chad Wolf says

U.S. Capitol Police failed to implement emergency security plans before the Jan. 6 riots...

Greenwald Explains How Biden’s Neoliberal Policies To Fuel Rise Of A “Smarter, More Stable Donald Trump”

Pulitzer prize-winning journalist Glenn Greenwald, formerly of The Intercept, gave his broad assessment and predictions of the incoming Joe Biden administration during Chris Hedges' Sunday show On...

Trump’s 1776 Commission Calls for National Unity Around America’s Founding Values

President Donald Trump’s advisory 1776 Commission on Monday released a public report, fulfilling its task to revisit the nation’s founding history in an effort...

Sen. Josh Hawley lands new publisher for ‘Big Tech’ book after Simon & Schuster balks

Sen. Josh Hawley has found a new publisher for his upcoming book targeting Big Tech censorship, less than two weeks since Simon & Schuster...