20.6 C
Houston
Friday, February 26, 2021

Pentagon Intelligence Purchased Troves Of Warrantless Phone Location Data On Americans

Authored by Brett Wilkins via CommonDreams.org,

Digital rights advocates reacted with alarm to a report published Friday detailing how Defense Intelligence Agency analysts in recent years bought databases of US smartphone location data without first obtaining warrants

The Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA) is part of the Department of Defense and is tasked with informing military and civilian policymakers about the activities and intentions of foreign governments and nonstate actors. 

- Advertisement -
File image: Alamy/Wired

The new revelation, first reported by the New York Times, initially came in the form of DIA responses to questions from Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) regarding the agency’s warrantless purchase of commercial location data generated by phones both inside and outside of the United States. 

Wyden asked the DIA to clarify its interpretation of Carpenter v. United States, a 2018 U.S. Supreme Court decision barring law enforcement agencies from requesting personal location information from a cellphone company without first obtaining a search warrant from a judge.

“DIA does not construe the Carpenter decision to require a judicial warrant endorsing purchase or use of commercially-available data for intelligence purposes,” the agency replied, implicitly acknowledging its exploitation of an apparent loophole in the case that DIA believes permits its warrantless acquisition of location data from third-party brokers

Furthermore, Wyden asked whether DIA operatives differentiated between phone location data obtained inside the U.S. and abroad. 

“DIA’s data provider does not supply separate streams of U.S. and foreign location data,” the agency explained, “and so DIA processes the location data as it arrives to identify U.S. location data points, which it segregates in a separate database.”

“DIA personnel can only query this database of U.S. location data when authorized by the DIA chief of staff and DIA’s office of general counsel,” it added. “Permission to query DIA’s database of commercially acquired US device location data has been granted five times in the past two-and-a-half years, when DIA first started buying this source of data.” 

Last September it was revealed that the US military was purchasing device location data from apps—including a Muslim prayer app used by tens of millions of people around the world—and using it for counterterrorism purposes. 

“The military industrial complex and the surveillance state have always had a cozy relationship with tech,” Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-Minn.) said at the time. “Buying bulk data in order to profile Muslims is par for the course for them—and is absolutely sickening. It should be illegal!”

To that end, the ACLU in December filed a lawsuit to determine how and why federal agencies are buying access to bulk databases of Americans’ cellphone location information and skirting  the Fourth Amendment’s warrant requirement.

And as The Hill reported Friday, Wyden plans to introduce legislation—the Fourth Amendment Is Not for Sale Act—which would prohibit government agencies from buying personal information from data brokers

“I think we’ve really reached the point where you have so much data floating around that governments can essentially buy their way around the Fourth Amendment,” Wyden lamented last November. 

In a Senate speech on Wednesday, Wyden condemned the status quo “in which the government, instead of getting an order, just goes out and purchases the private records of Americans from these sleazy and unregulated commercial data brokers who are simply above the law.”

Digital and pivacy rights advocates agree. 

“The government cannot simply buy our private data in order to bypass bedrock constitutional protections,” senior ACLU staff attorney Ashley Gorski told The Hill. “Congress must end this lawless practice and require the government to get a warrant for our location data, regardless of its source.”

News of the DIA warrantless data acquisition came a day after Avril Haines was sworn in as President Joe Biden’s director of national intelligence. Haines will oversee the nation’s 18 intelligence agencies, including the DIA.

Wyden supports Haines’ appointment, in part due to what he called her “commitments related to transparency issues.” A broad range of progressive groups, however, strongly opposed her nomination. 

During her Senate confirmation hearing earlier this week, Wyden asked Haines about government abuse of commercially available location data.

“I would seek to try to publicize, essentially, a framework that helps people understand the circumstances under which we do that and the legal basis that we do that under,” she replied. “I think that’s part of what’s critical to promoting transparency generally so that people have an understanding of the guidelines under which the intelligence community operates.”



Zerohedge

Latest news

California Collapsing | ZeroHedge

Authored by Martin Sieff via The Strategic Culture Foundation,California now fulfills Fyodor Dostoyevsky’s nightmare vision in his prophetic masterpiece “The Possessed” as to what...

A man left his baby in an illegally parked car and a Chicago worker towed them away. The dad was charged with child endangerment.

A man is facing charges after he left his 5-month-baby in an illegally parked car that was towed away by a city tow truck...

“It’s Bananas” – 72% Of US Homebuyers Say Pandemic Disrupted Plans

Americans have been fascinated by market trends during the pandemic era, as everything from bitcoin, to baseball cards, is seeing prices rise, and central...

Senate Parliamentarian Rules $15 Minimum Wage Cannot Be Included in COVID-19 Stimulus Bill

The Senate parliamentarian ruled Thursday that the $15 per hour minimum wage cannot be included in the Democrats’ proposed $1.9 trillion COVID-19 stimulus package. The...

Related news

California Collapsing | ZeroHedge

Authored by Martin Sieff via The Strategic Culture Foundation,California now fulfills Fyodor Dostoyevsky’s nightmare vision in his prophetic masterpiece “The Possessed” as to what...

A man left his baby in an illegally parked car and a Chicago worker towed them away. The dad was charged with child endangerment.

A man is facing charges after he left his 5-month-baby in an illegally parked car that was towed away by a city tow truck...

“It’s Bananas” – 72% Of US Homebuyers Say Pandemic Disrupted Plans

Americans have been fascinated by market trends during the pandemic era, as everything from bitcoin, to baseball cards, is seeing prices rise, and central...

Senate Parliamentarian Rules $15 Minimum Wage Cannot Be Included in COVID-19 Stimulus Bill

The Senate parliamentarian ruled Thursday that the $15 per hour minimum wage cannot be included in the Democrats’ proposed $1.9 trillion COVID-19 stimulus package. The...

Maryland Teacher Seen Masturbating During Zoom Lesson with 8th Graders

Maryland teacher’s aide Mark Schack was caught on camera masturbating during an 8th grade virtual lesson earlier this week. When Schack spoke with FOX 5...

McConnell would ‘absolutely’ support Trump if he was the 2024 GOP nominee

Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell said he would support former President Donald Trump if...

In Final Days, Trump Gave Up On Forcing Release Of Russiagate Files, Nunes Investigator Says

Authored by Aaron Maté via RealClear Investigations (emphasis ours),After four years of railing against “deep state” actors who, he said, tried to undermine his...

McConnell says he’ll absolutely support Trump if he’s the nominee in 2024, but there’s more…

Mitch McConnell was asked by Bret Baier tonight if he would support Trump if he won the Republican nomination in 2024. (cued up to 9:30) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jkz_INkYDAc Even...