15.7 C
Houston
Wednesday, March 3, 2021

Stocks Are Doing Something They Haven’t Done Since The Dot Com Bubble

With 66 S&P 500 companies, representing 22% of S&P 500 earnings, having already reported Q4 earnings, there was some good, some not so good, and some downright bizarre news this earnings season.

- Advertisement -

First, the good news: as Bank of America’s Savita Subramanian reports, S&P EPS rose 2% last week to $38.70 (-8% YoY) and 73% of companies have beaten on both sales and EPS, tracking similar to last quarter when we ultimately saw a record number of beats. This means that as of this moment, 4Q earnings are clearing BofA’s – and the consensus – EPS estimate by over 2% (but ex-Financials, earnings are tracking just 1% above expectations at the start of January). Despite Financials’ beat and overall positive 2021 guide, which was largely due to billions in reserve releases, the sector has lagged with Growth & Tech driving the S&P 500’s 2% return last week according to BofA’s Subramanian who however repeats that the bank “sees signs of a last gasp Growth trade, and advise sticking with Value.”

In the not so good news category, BofA notes that while S&P 500 non-Financial net margins unexpectedly rose 10bps YoY to 11.3%,  – pointing to aggressive cost control implemented by companies – analysts expect a 70bps drop in net margins YoY to 10.2% in 4Q. Of the 10 sectors (ex-Fins), only Materials is expected to see higher margins YoY (+1.0ppt). Indeed, the bank’s own Corporate Misery Indicator, which has been strongly correlated with, and sometimes led, the profits cycle, also took a pause in 4Q, indicating sluggish earnings recovery in 4Q.

That said, there was a silver lining to the expected margin contraction: BofA’s predictive analytics team used earnings calls transcripts to calculate sentiment for S&P500 companies that have reported this earnings season. It found that corporate sentiment remains positive so far and is now largely unchanged vs. pre-COVID 4Q19 levels, despite a weaker reading vs. last quarter on a YoY basis. That said, sentiment is expected to continue to improve from here as the economy reopens.

Which brings us to the downright bizarre: with the S&P 500 trading at an all-time high and rich valuations, BofA observes that there has been no reward for beats so far this earnings season (similar to last quarter) in fact, a record 1.6% underperformance penalty – for beats. Are investors rewarding positive outlooks (where 2021 expectations have risen by 1.5% since Jan. 1)? Quite the opposite: so far we see a very unusual penalty for raising guidance – 20bps of negative 1-day alpha vs. the average positive 2ppt alpha since 2007. What this means is that companies which beat on both sales and EPS underperformed the S&P 500 by 1.6% the following day, representing the worst reactions in BofA data history going back to the dot com bubble days of 2000! 

It gets crazier: where there were also no rewards for above-consensus guidance (-20bps vs. +2.1ppt on average since 2007), companies which missed on both revenue and EPS actually outperformed the S&P the next day!

Why does this matter? Well, the last time we saw such a reaction to earnings was in Q2 2000… after which the S&P 500 fell by 13% over the next three months amid a marked change in leadership, with Value outperforming growth by over 25ppt.

Zerohedge

Latest news

Andrew Cuomo introduces COVID-19 passports for residents hoping to attend sporting events

New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo announced a plan that would require residents of the...

Biden Admin Planning For Influx Of 117,000 Illegal Youths To US This Year

Authored by Steve Watson via Summit News,Internal documents outline that the Biden administration is planning to integrate 117,000 migrant youths and children in 2021,...

Liberals claimed CPAC stage was Nazi symbol. But company whose founder is ‘very liberal’ designed stage.

Liberals claimed over the weekend that the stage used at the Conservative Political Action Conference resembled symbols used by German Nazis. But, as it turned...

Dem Sen. Padilla: As Long as Trump, GOP Push ‘the Big Lie’ We Face ‘Real Imminent Danger of Extremists’

During Wednesday’s broadcast of “CNN Newsroom,” Sen. Alex Padilla (D-CA) warned that if former President Donald Trump and the Republican Party continue to perpetuate...

Related news

Andrew Cuomo introduces COVID-19 passports for residents hoping to attend sporting events

New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo announced a plan that would require residents of the...

Biden Admin Planning For Influx Of 117,000 Illegal Youths To US This Year

Authored by Steve Watson via Summit News,Internal documents outline that the Biden administration is planning to integrate 117,000 migrant youths and children in 2021,...

Liberals claimed CPAC stage was Nazi symbol. But company whose founder is ‘very liberal’ designed stage.

Liberals claimed over the weekend that the stage used at the Conservative Political Action Conference resembled symbols used by German Nazis. But, as it turned...

Democrats tighten stimulus check limits in bid to smooth passage of $1.9 trillion spending bill

The Senate Wednesday is slated to advance a $1.9 trillion spending package after working...

New York rolls out pilot COVID-19 passport program for entering public venues

New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo (D) on Tuesday announced a pilot program testing a new COVID-19 electronic passport for entering public venues as the...

D.C. Police Issue Emergency Alert On “Possible” Militia Plot To Breach Capitol Tomorrow

Here we go again with yet more vague "threats" by nebulous militant right-wing groups targeting the Capitol which will no doubt be met with...

Tim Allen says he ‘kind of liked’ it when Trump ‘pissed people off’

Actor Tim Allen says he was amused by the antics of former President Donald...

‘Militia Group’ Possibly Plotting to Breach the Capitol on March 4: Capitol Police

The U.S. Capitol Police said that it learned of a possible threat against members of Congress and the Capitol complex by “an identified militia...