15.7 C
Wednesday, March 3, 2021

Team Trump and Team Black Lives Matter are more alike than you think

In the wake of protesters (rioters?) breaking windows and rumbling through the Capitol on Jan. 6, many have rightly noted a certain amount of hypocrisy threading through both the news coverage of and the rhetoric surrounding the incident.

Neither the Democrats nor the legacy media appeared as agitated about the “peaceful protests” this summer, which were more destructive, more lethal and involved at least as many federal buildings as did the riot (protest?) on Jan. 6.

That’s fine. Everyone chooses to emphasize different things in life. But no one has emphasized or even mentioned the substantial similarities and the relatively modest differences between the Trump crew and Team Black Lives Matter.

- Advertisement -

At their core, they are bound together by grievances against the state and the polity it represents.

In each instance, the aggrieved party believes — with some justification — that it has been marginalized by the government or by the larger society or both. The banning of President Trump from Twitter and Facebook and the immediate shunning of Parler won’t help any of that.

Team Trump wants the state to stop damaging them through trade deals, immigration and a general drift toward a society that it views as unrecognizable and that rewards the wrong sorts of things.

Team BLM and its sympathizers believe that the state – as expressed through law enforcement, housing and most especially education — is indifferent to it at best and intentionally destructive at worst. At the moment, they want the state to do “better,” which seems to mean “more.” They eventually will discover that it is better if the state involves itself less in their lives.

Team Trump is farther down the path toward concluding that they have been voting for the wrong kinds of people for years. BLM sympathizers still need a few years to fully realize that they, too, have been voting for the wrong people for generations.

In each set of protests (and here’s where there can be legitimate differences), the parties have been treated more or less with the same sort of laissez faire approach by law enforcement. In the summer, protesters were not gunned down and few were arrested. At the Capitol, the protesters were not gunned down and all but a handful were not arrested.

Both groups also share a sense that some of their problems can be solved by government.

The federal government doesn’t solve problems. Occasionally, government ameliorates a problem by throwing cash at it, or rearranging organizational responsibilities, or killing a nation’s enemies, but for the most part it doesn’t solve problems. People do. By inventing things, or creating new ways of doing things, or – as is required here – by changing hearts and minds, people solve problems.

Government does, however, create problems. It is here that the Trump crew is closest to correct. Their grievances center on trade, immigration and, when they are coherent, the size and scope of government (pay no mind to the fact that Mr. Trump expanded both the government and the deficit at some of the most impressive rates in history).

BLM is asking for something – to be considered by their fellow citizens as true equals — that no government can give. Only individual consciences and God can make that happen.

If there is systemic racism, which is not yet a fact in evidence, the government is unlikely to solve it. 

Finally, with respect to both teams’ interactions with the government – whether it be law enforcement, administration of justice, housing, immigration, trade, or – most pointedly — education, both groups find themselves on the wrong end of a government that ranges from diffident to hostile.

Indeed, they both now fully understand that government – which in all places and at all times claims a monopoly on legitimate violence – only acts decisively when you start damaging their property. In the week since the rumble in the Capitol, the federal government has managed to assemble and deploy the equivalent of almost two armored divisions in Washington. It has become Baghdad on the Potomac, complete with its own Green Zone.

That’s one other, final and unfortunate similarity between the two groups. To both, the government is usually better at offering force than understanding.

• Michael McKenna, a columnist for The Washington Times, is the president of MWR Strategies. He was most recently a deputy assistant to the president and deputy director of the Office of Legislative Affairs at the White House.


Latest news

In 2017, Kamala Harris Celebrated Dr. Seuss’s Birthday

Vice President Kamala Harris celebrated the birthday of Dr. Seuss in 2017, even though President Joe Biden’s administration tried to cancel the children’s author...

“Space Hurricane” Spotted Above North Pole, Study Finds  

For the first time, a team of researchers from China, the US, Norway, and the UK, have spotted an eye-catching phenomenon above the North...

Andrew Cuomo introduces COVID-19 passports for residents hoping to attend sporting events

New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo announced a plan that would require residents of the...

Is there any reason to think this time will be different?

When public policies have produced disastrous results, and when alternative policies have resulted in...

Related news

Is there any reason to think this time will be different?

When public policies have produced disastrous results, and when alternative policies have resulted in...

Biden Border Policy Is A ‘Magnet’ For Migrant Trafficking

Federalist Political Editor John Daniel Davidson warned on Wednesday of the border crisis already taking place on the southern border, where smugglers rake in...

Al Franken’s undoing was not a ‘rush to judgement,’ and neither is Andrew Cuomo’s

Because yet one more prominent member of their own party is facing accusations of...

Dr. Seuss didn’t write for the outrage mob

Like most parents, I could probably recite a handful of children’s books from memory....

The Cancellation Of Dr. Seuss Should Disturb You, Because You’re Next

Dr. Seuss has been cancelled. Some of his work has been deemed racist, and we can’t have that. On Tuesday, the entity that oversees...

Cuomo’s Nursing Home Scandal Also Killed Priceless Cultural Memories

Few doubt that New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s policy of sending COVID-19 patients into nursing homes led to a huge spike in deaths of...

To protect free speech, protect the Digital Millennium Copyright Act

Allegations of online bias and political censorship simmered throughout the last presidential election, culminating...