16.6 C
Houston
Saturday, November 28, 2020

Will The Trump Team Prove A Global Conspiracy Or Will Dominion Sue For Defamation?

As we detailed previously, yesterday’s press conference held by the Trump legal team was not for the faint of heart.

As Jonathan Turley writes, the team alleged a global, Communist-backed conspiracy to “inject” and “change” votes through the use of the Dominion computer system. It was exhausting and breathtaking. I was critical of the press conference as being long on heated rhetoric and short on hard evidence. Dominion issued a statement categorically denying the allegations.

The question is whether Dominion itself will now sue.  The company denied the allegations but I often measure such denials by whether anyone actually sues.  Dominion could do so and force the Trump team to reveal the evidence supporting their allegations or face potentially significant liability. I assume that counsel like Sidney Powell would not make such allegations without proof, but the press conference did not make such evidence public. But these are not just colorful but criminal allegations against named companies and by implication corporate officials and political allies.

Trump campaign counsel repeatedly accused Dominion and its officers of criminal conduct and business improprieties. Those are categories of “per se defamation” under the common law. No special damages must be shown in such per se cases. Individual officers could bring defamation claims and the company itself could bring a business disparagement action.

Businesses can be defamed like individuals if the false statement injures the business character of the corporation or its prestige and standing in the industry. In Dun & Bradstreet, Inc. v. Greenmoss Builders, Inc., 472 U.S. 749 (1985) the Supreme Court allowed a business to sue a credit reporting agency for defamation where the agency mistakenly reported that the business had filed for bankruptcy.

Restatement Second § 561 Defamation of Corporations states:

“One who publishes defamatory matter concerning a corporation is subject to liability to it

(a)  if the corporation is one for profit, and the matter tends to prejudice it in the conduct of its business or to deter others from dealing with it, or

(b)  if, although not for profit, it depends upon financial support from the public, and the matter tends to interfere with its activities by prejudicing it in public estimation.”

Dominion appears to be a company with a Colorado headquarters.

There could be lawsuits in Colorado or the place of the alleged defamation. The lawsuit would likely be filed under state law but moved to federal court under diversity jurisdiction arguments.

The press conference was an explosion of potentially defamatory claims by individuals or companies.  The only clear defense is truth.  The team insists that it can prove these allegations.  It may have to do so. Not only can the individual lawyers face such lawsuits but the Trump campaign itself could be liable under the principle of respondeat superior, where an employer is liable for the conduct of his employees when they are acting within the scope of their employment. Ironically, the Latin term means “let the master speak.” The President or his campaign could be forced to speak in a defamation case if they have not spoken in the promised court filings.

There is a question of privilege for legal claims.  There is an absolute privilege for lawyers in making statements in court. That is important because we often voice allegations that impute the veracity or character of parties, particularly in criminal cases. However, that privilege is more limited outside of court. It can still apply but some courts have refused to protect statements made to the press or the public. World Wresting Fed Entertainment, Inc v Bozell142 F Supp 2d 514, 534 (SDNY 2001); Kennedy v Cannon229 Md 92, 97, 182 A2d 54, 58 (1962).

In other words, if the Trump team does not put forward this evidence in its case challenging the election, it could now be forced to produce it in a case brought by Dominion or its officers.



Zerohedge

Latest news

A Key Time For Gold

Authored by Sven Henrich via NorthmanTrader.com,I wanted to offer some thoughts on Gold on this Thanksgiving weekend as Gold has reached a key price...

Paris protesters burn cars, set bank on fire over police brutality bill

Cars were set alight and the Central Bank of France building was hit with a fire missile in Paris Saturday as tens of thousands...

NY Times taken to woodshed for claiming Iran’s nuclear program is ‘peaceful’: ‘Is this an Iranian paper?’

The New York Times was summarily blasted on Saturday after the newspaper presented Iran's nuclear program in a positive light. The Times' posturing came...

Related news

A Key Time For Gold

Authored by Sven Henrich via NorthmanTrader.com,I wanted to offer some thoughts on Gold on this Thanksgiving weekend as Gold has reached a key price...

NY Times taken to woodshed for claiming Iran’s nuclear program is ‘peaceful’: ‘Is this an Iranian paper?’

The New York Times was summarily blasted on Saturday after the newspaper presented Iran's nuclear program in a positive light. The Times' posturing came...

COVID Antibody Drugs From Regeneron, Eli Lilly Raise Concerns About Supply Shortages

Powerful drugs recently authorized by the FDA are expected to help patients suffering from the earliest stages of COVID-19 avoid the most severe symptoms....

Protester Says This Election Fraud Amounts to Treason

MADISON—Dan Ampe says the election fraud has shown that corruption in American institutions have reached levels he never would have imagined even in his...

Ted Cruz shoots down Brennan for siding with Iran after assassination of top Iranian scientist

Yesterday a top Iranian scientist, responsible for Iran’s nuclear program, was assassinated in a shootout with unknown assailants:An Iranian scientist that Israel alleged led...

Two teenagers dead in California after Black Friday mall shooting

Two teenagers died after a shooting at a mall in Sacramento, California. ...

NY Gym Owner Rips Up $15,000 Lockdown Fine On Live TV: “We Will Not Comply”

Submitted by Rusty Weiss of The Mental Recession,Robby Dinero, the owner of Athletes Unleashed gym located in Orchard Park, New York, tore up a...

‘We Cannot Let Evil Back Into the White House’

HARRISBURG, Pa.—Wendy Dominski, from upstate New York, traveled to Pennsylvania to join protests against election fraud, because it is a battleground state where evidence...